I'm a big U2 fan, I've seen them 4 times in concert, but this CD is a real yawn. Since Achtung Baby I've found it hard to get into some of their CDs, but I don't really even want to try with this one. I don't think these songs would go over very well in a concert either. They just don't hold up to U2's huge catalogue of great tunes. This CD is a 2 out of 5, not more than that.